My fiancee and I are planning to go to Central or South America for our honeymoon at the end of March '15 and so far, Belize and Costa Rica sound the most promising. Our budget is about $5K. We'd love an all-inclusive resort, a lot of beach time, but some adventure time as well. We'd also love to eat some local cuisine, maybe see some wild monkeys and birds--but no snakes (she hates them). Snorkeling/Scuba is probably out as I can't swim, but I'm open to water activities with a life jacket.
Any idea whether Belize or Costa Rica would be better for this? Is there somewhere else we should consider?